UbiComp 2010: Paper of MY Conference

So while this paper was not nominated for best paper, and should not have been, it did quite a bit for me personally in terms of considering structure for my own future thesis.

Andrea Grimes, Vasudhara Kantroo and Rebecca E. Grinter (2010). Let's Play! Mobile Health Games for Adults. Proc. of UBICOMP 2010. (Link is to Ms.Grimes website, and you can find the full paper on the publications page.)

Let me sum up the gist of the idea, rather than going into the details of the paper, as there are some fundamental problems with the study. The gist is that a casual game might be better suited for games that aim to improve behavior. The behavior here was based on healthy eating, and the research targeted African American individuals because of the high incidence of diabetes among that population. The game was designed with food items that such folks would find in their neighborhoods, including soul food type items, sandwiches, etc.

The critical part for me was the introduction of the casual game premise. I had been structuring my thesis idea around epistemic games, thinking only in terms of long story arc type things, and listening to this proposal has given me an alternate idea. I'm definitely going to need to start with an exploratory study to examine which of those two paths is going to be the better choice for me, I think. Additionally, discussing the shape of the study and what might have been a better question for the study format has helped me think about how to structure my own studies to avoid those types of critiques.

I'm likely going to blog about a few more of the papers that were interesting or that I discussed in a critical fashion with Leilah as well.

Academics: Very Smart, Very Dumb

I have one major complaint about UbiComp 2010 as far as comfort goes. The seatting arrangement during the presentations is a typical lecture hall, but one with absolutely no space to move if someone is sitting in a chair. For some reason, every single person will opt to sit on the very end of the row. This means that every person who is not in the lecture hall before the presentation begins has to squeeze past those folks who sat down first. This is particularly difficult as some folks refuse to stand up to let people pass.

This is particularly humiliating in my case. I'm not a small woman by most standards, and it. is. not. comfortable. for me to move myself and my laptop pass you. You're forcing me to choose to show you either my rear or my front in a small area. It is awkward for me. I can't imagine you're enjoying it that much, given your reluctance to even stand up. When I say "Excuse me," it isn't a request for you to turn your knees to the side, which adds maybe three inches to the first three that were there. I'm simply not six inches wide.

So please, colleagues. If you're organizing a conference, do choose a venue that it is accessible for various body types. If you're at a conference that doesn't have wide aisles, either sit near the center of the row, or be prepared to stand up when people need to get by.

A further update about UbiComp as far as interesting papers went will be posted either later today or tomorrow.